This post was originally shared on Reddit where it was read by over 200,000 people. Sharing it here for anyone who finds it through search.
I had four gym memberships that never really started. A business idea I kept preparing to begin. A language I was going to learn. And somehow YouTube and phone scrolling kept winning every single day.
Sound familiar?
I am an engineer by background. When something keeps failing I want to understand the mechanism. So I dug into the research.
Here is what is actually happening:
Motivation = (Expectancy x Value) ÷ (Pain x Delay)
Expectancy is whether you believe you can do it. Value is why it matters to you. Pain is the effort and fear of starting. Delay is how far away the reward feels.
Your brain runs this calculation automatically before every action and picks the highest scoring option. Not the most important one. The highest scoring one right now.
Starting a business: you are not sure you can do it, the reward is years away, the effort and risk are high. Score is low. Your brain moves on.
Going to the gym: you know how but it is uncomfortable, the results take months. Score is medium at best.
Learning a language: consistent practice required, progress invisible for a long time. Score is low.
Scrolling YouTube: you can always do it, it feels fine, zero effort, reward is immediate. Score is maximum.
So your brain optimises for the highest instant reward every time. Not because you are weak. Because this is how human neurology works. It is an energy efficiency bias built into the system.
The formula tells you which variable to fix.
Low expectancy? Make the first step so small your brain cannot doubt you can do it. Not start a business. Just write one sentence about the idea today.
High pain? Remove one obstacle. Not all of them. One. What is making starting harder than it needs to be right now.
Long delay? Create an immediate reward just for starting. Not for finishing. Just for beginning. For me it is my morning coffee ritual. An Ethiopian V60 I take time to brew properly. I only allow myself to fully enjoy it when I have started the one thing I was avoiding. Small, immediate, mine. Find yours.
I used this to understand why I kept avoiding things I genuinely wanted to do. Once I could see which variable was broken I stopped trying harder and started fixing the right thing.
One thing I noticed personally: Value turned out to be the most important variable for complex long term goals. Starting a business, preparing for an important exam, learning something difficult. If the reason is not genuinely yours the whole formula breaks down. Not your parents goal. Not what you think you should want. Yours. Everything else can be adjusted. A borrowed why cannot.
If this landed, there is one piece every week at stillnavigating.com — honest writing about the stuck middle, from someone still in it.